Gram and Imma on Punctuation


Imma:   “Punctuation is a tool.  Yes, there are rules, but rules were meant to be broken.  Somtimes in life we use tools in ways they were not created for, such as using a bat as a hammer or a screw driver as a prying tool.   Tools can function in other ways than those given in the instruction books; they can perform other functions in a pinch.  The same is true for punctuation.  Many great classics have what others might consider mis-used punctuation.  The writer chose to use it in a way that he or she felt added to the work.”

Gram:  “Rules exist for a reason.  Can you imagine if people were to place punctuation willy nilly wherever they wanted!  Uniformity (rule following) allows us to know what’s expected of us and to read what others write.  We need a normative function for punctuation just like we need a common language to communicate well with the people in our sphere.”

Imma:  “I didn’t say throw the rules out!  I just said don’t be so compulsive about it.  Learn the rules, use them, but don’t sweat it if it’s not perfect or bending a rule enhances the readability of the piece.”

 

Imma and Gram are, again, both correct.  Punctuation rules allow us to all speak the same language in our writing.  However, there are times when bending those rules lends something new and exciting to the piece.  If used in moderation and not just because you do not understand the rules of punctuation, it can lead to new worlds in your writing.  There are numerous “punctuation checkers” on the web if you wish to double check your work.  You can also find tutorials, but make sure they come from a reputable source.   As always:  when in doubt:  ASK!

7 Comments

  1. As with most concepts, there are different ways to interpret rules and apply them. I like the different perspectives! Yes I ask when I’m not sure, two heads are better than one :)

    • True Christy, it is all about perspective.

  2. maturestudenthanginginthere

    You popped into my blog a couple of times and I followed your link tonight. First chance I’ve had, life has been crazy busy. “Rules are meant to be broken” you sound like my kind of blogger AND it looks as though you could teach me a thing or two. Interesting blog. I’m off to subscribe and look forward to reading more. Thanks for stopping by my blog and reading. I really appreciate it.

    • Well, welcome to Gram and Imma’s place! I’m glad you could stop in. Gram and Imma are a study in opposites living in the same brain – mine. Wacky world for sure. I hope you enjoyed it and stop back again when you have the time. Angie

  3. But what if someone—what the heck—a LOT of people (nowadays) don’t have any perspective? Don’t know when to ask because they have no idea they need help. That’s the hard part. And it’s sad.

    • That would be a big problem for sure. If you publish on the web (articles) you should find out pretty quickly where problems lie. It is difficult for even the best grammar nazis sometimes, so for others it can be a nightmare. I guess I would ask if problems exist (friends and followers) and go from there. Conversationally (some blog posts or comments), I don’ worry about it too much. I’ll have to think on that one:)

  4. You got me at punctuation :-) Thanks for stopping by my site, as well.

    margo

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 406 other followers

%d bloggers like this: